Tahq....last thing I want is argument so I'm in agreement with you. In this post the talk has been about snipers in war and/or punching paper or busting steel, not shooting game. Regarding my Sharps I'd certainly take a 200 yard shot if I had the time to adjust the sights and a good rest. I have two settings on the sights on my hunting Sharps, 100 and 200 yards. Beyond that I simply wouldn't shoot. Shooting any of my muzzleloaders with conventional open sights and PRB, 100 yards is my absolute max and I'd prefer it at half that. I'm also shooting a 480 gr. bullet which is considerably heavier than a jacketed, saboted pistol bullet and retains quite a bit more energy than the pistol bullets.
Regarding a long range muzzleloader the Whitworth would be hard to beat, from what I understand, if you can find one. From what's been said in this thread evidently they've become hard to find. Back in the late 1800's and early 1900's there were numerous makers of fine long range muzzleloaders. Wesson and Brockway are two that come to mind. If one was so inclined I believe you could find a maker to duplicate one of their rifles complete with false muzzle with cross patch and cutter. I doubt it would be cheap tho. As many of those as there were out there I'd think an original could be found but again it wouldn't be cheap I'm sure. Those old guys did some incredible work all the way out to 1000 yards. This is a discipline of muzzleloading that is conspicuous by it's absence on virtually all ML forums. I wonder where all those old rifles are and where the interest in them is?
Vic