It really doesn't "fit" anywhere well (imho). The stock is sorta shaped like post 1800 and the rear sight is buckhorn so is very much post 1800, BUT the lock is very large and the caliber of .54 in a 39" barrel is more pre-AWI. No wooden patch box nor metal patch box (unless you buy the "deluxe" version) nor even a tallow hole..., and the use of the ramrod thimbles as "washers" to hold the barrel to the stock is circa 1970's and later. :wink:
Some people say the "Hatfield" rifle was based on an original owned by the family, but I have yet to find out if the original "Hatfield" rifle is being confused with the Pedersoli Frontier, which was ordered by Hatfield with better than basic wood, and a polish and blue on the barrel, in the latter years of that company. One assertion I read was the Pedersoli Frontier was a copy of the Hatfield family's rifle, but I think that's conjecture, blending the original Hatfield story with the later Italian rifle contracted by the Hatfield Company and assuming the story refers to the Frontier from Pedersoli.
I suspect this because the stock shape of the Frontier is very different from any other style that would have been present when the "original Hatfield rifle" would have been made, and its shape would not have been easy to produce. Further, Pedersoli (I'm confident) would not miss the opportunity to tell its customers if they were selling a copy of an original rifle, although they say it "reproduces faithfully" a copy of a long rifle from 1760-1840. :shocked2: Which is a pretty long time in the evolution of the American Long Rifle and many many changes took place in those 8 decades. :shake:
It works as the best currently produced, factory, flintlock "long rifle" useable for big game and available in a caliber larger than .50. Under .54 you have the Traditions Pennsylvania flintlock in .50 and the Pedersoli Pennsylvania flintlock in .45.
Now as a factory flintlock they are good looking rifles, and shoot pretty well. I liked mine in the past and I'm thinking when the go on sale again (usually after New Year's) I will buy one for my son. I missed the sale this year..., too slow on my part.
LD