You should be able to rebrown the area but before you do, try your best to rub off the orange material with a rough piece of cloth like bluejeans are made from.
If you can get the orange material rubbed off, lightly oil the area. It should return to the brown color of the area around it.
(Browning is just a hard rust. The orange or red stuff is soft rust).
If that doesn't do the job and you really need to rebrown the area it must be totally free of all oil, grease or wax.
A light sanding with some 220 or 320 grit paper to roughen up the surface and then applying some Laurel Mountain browning agent (or some other brand) and exposing it to warm, humid air should cause it to start rusting.
It may take several applications so rub off any loose, red rust that forms and apply another coating of the browning agent.
Although the new browning will look lighter than the surrounding area when it is first done, it will darken a great deal once some gun oil has been applied.