Zonie said:
Yes, modern .410's use heavier loads but then, we are not trying to duplicate modern guns with our muzzleloaders are we?
Well...just a little different angle as more food for thought...modern .410s are modern in both cases. The 2 different over the counter .410 shot loads are 1/2oz and 9/16oz...both are modern .410 loads so if one cannot be duplicated because its modern I'm not sure how the other one can. Also, it may well be that the data in that catalog is simply real old and it didn't list the 9/16oz load.
Since primary thoughts are about pressure, then followed closely by performance, how much does a 1/2 or 9/16oz volumetric load of lead shot actually weigh?
And actual weight of each shot charge will vary all over of course, with different physical size shot and correspondingly different amounts of empty air space between all the pellets.
Muzzleloaders operating with slower burning powders, much lower pressures, no shot cups, and no chokes is why the old saying still survives today: "little powder, more lead, shoots far, kills dead"
Depending on if skeet, trap, turkey, squirrels, no shot cup and no choke, I don't always load a good quality BP smoothbore with the same shot charges typically found in the modern shotshell world...apples and oranges as far as I'm concerned.
EXAMPLE: 15/16" x .54cal(.28ga) GM Flint cylinder bore smoothbore barrel:
Skeet = 60grns 3F & 7/8oz #9s
Trap = 70grns 3F & 1.0oz #8s
Squirrels = 70grns 3F & 1+3/8oz #5s
Turkey = 70grns 3F & 1+3/8oz #6s
PS:
In our liability concious, sue at the drop of a hat world, my disclaimer is:
"Now don't you kids try this at home"
:wink: