I'd say they're six in one, half a dozen in the other. I have guns from both companies but do not have those specific ones. My Traditions Deer Hunter is 1 of the most accurate guns I own, don't get me wrong, my investarm/lymans shoot good but the deer hunter will cloverleaf at 50yds all day as long if I do my part. I think fit and finish is better in the investarm guns, I'd give feel and function to them as well. Would end with both being equally reliable so I guess my opinion would be which one speaks to you the most.