How much is too much.

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

Joined
Nov 2, 2006
Messages
298
Reaction score
655
Location
Los Lunas, NM
Reminds me, I need to weigh my just completed Lancaster, .54, swamped Colerain, CM4 stock, L&R classic lock. It's lighter than my Kibler colonial in .58 I'm pretty sure. Rifles get cumbersome when heavy AND long as the balance point tends to be out there, especially with a non-tapered or swamped barrel. I'm looking forward to the Kibler Woodsrunner project with the slightly shorter, swamped .54 barrel in a regular grade maple stock build. That rifle should be a very nimble setup.
 
Joined
Dec 30, 2004
Messages
2,891
Reaction score
2,452
Location
New England
Varies with barrel length AND barrel width - if a straight profile barrel, like T/C or Lyman uses, OR profile if a swamped barrel.

But to give you an idea, usually if of the SAME model and length, a 5-cal would be a good 1/2-pound or more LESS in weight that a comparable 50cal model.

The Kibler Colonial Rifle of 42" swamped barrel wighs a hefty 9.0 pounds. I had a Don Bruton 54 Boone rifle of slimmer 38" barrel that was a dream to carry, at less than 8-pounds. The weight of the Colonial Rifle is why Jim came out with the shorter and lighter 'Woods Runner' model.

As someone else offered, the school or year of model, also determines the weight. Like early rifles (the Colonial Rifle certainly being one) had much heftier and wider buttplates, so that addes overall weight. Golden Age longrifles slimmed down and are trimmer and lighter.
 
Joined
Jul 11, 2022
Messages
63
Reaction score
20
Location
Colorado
Correct, that’s why I build the golden age profile. It’s really no big deal. I’ll just throw her over my shoulder and hump it up the hill. It’s just my OCD personality. But you have to be a little obsessive to want to build your own rifles in the first place. Thanks for all the good info guys.
 
Joined
Feb 9, 2020
Messages
1,154
Reaction score
2,073
Location
New England
My Kibler Colonial, which I have 2 interchangeable barrels, a 50 and a 58, both with 43” swamped barrels weight in at 8.75 and 8.0 pounds respectively. Preferring the 58, the difference in weight and balance when off-hand shooting is quite noticeable.given my medium build. My buddy has a 54 Colonial which splits the difference in weight.. My 54 cal Hawken(Western Arms) with its heavy 1” by 30” straight barrel cones in a a hefty 10.5 pounds! 7.5-8.5# is my preferred weight range for hunting.
 

Montgomery

Defender of Truth & Faith, Lord of the Rift
MLF Supporter
Joined
Nov 23, 2022
Messages
150
Reaction score
170
Location
USA
My Lancaster .50 has a swamped 42 in barrel, weighs 9lb,2 oz. My Haines .54 has a swamped 38in barrel, weighs 7lbs. 12, My GPR .50 Hawken with 32 in straight barrel, weighs 9lbs 10oz. oz., My early Yorktown 44 in. 20 gauge Fowler by Brad Emig, weighs 7lb. 10 oz.
 

TerryK

40 Cal.
Joined
Jan 3, 2014
Messages
414
Reaction score
180
Location
Central PA
I had a Pedersoli Mortimer. Pedersoli said it is 10.13 pounds, but mine was 10 pounds 9 ounces.
It was pretty hard to carry all day. It was a great rifle, just too heavy for walking in the woods.
 
Joined
Jan 1, 2019
Messages
880
Reaction score
1,074
Location
Dark Side of the Moon
Most any straight barreled gun is going to feel heavy and awkward. A rifle with a swamped barrel can be just as heavy, but will feel far lighter because all the weight is back between your hands.
I have 3 schuetzen rifles that weigh from 13.5-15 1/2 lbs. I can shoot them off hand because of their architecture and buttplate style.
 
Top