• This community needs YOUR help today. We rely 100% on Supporting Memberships to fund our efforts. With the ever increasing fees of everything, we need help. We need more Supporting Members, today. Please invest back into this community. I will ship a few decals too in addition to all the account perks you get.



    Sign up here: https://www.muzzleloadingforum.com/account/upgrades

Bore Butter ingredients

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
What can I use that will allow me to get the three shots he was talking about in the article?
I use this as patch lube and no wiping between shots is needed.
815817.jpg
 
I've tried Hoppe's #9, but my office is small, and it smells too strong, so I switched to Elon Musk.

Lube wise, Chanel #5 doesn't work as well, but the gun smells nice. Too expensive per shot, though, IMO.

-Sentry44
 
Last edited:
I use Goex black powder, Joann fabrics #40 drill cloth for patches.

My friend and long time offhand shooter that wins a lot of matches taught me to use a little spray bottle with water and enough Murphy's Oil Soap to make it "slippery" between you thumb and finger. I shoot maybe 10 shots before I feel that crude ring build up. Just spray the patch until it's wet, not dripping, just wet.

I use spit on woods walks so I can load from the bag. I can shoot all 17 targets at nationals and never wipe the bore.
 
In a thousand years people will still be reading these posts!
They'll be asking AI what's the best lube 🤣 here's what ChatGPT said:

What is the best lube for a traditional Muzzleloader?

The best lube for a traditional Muzzleloader depends on the type of bullet and powder being used. Some common types of lubes for Muzzleloaders include:

  1. Beeswax: Beeswax is a common lube for Muzzleloaders, as it provides a good barrier against fouling and helps to reduce friction.
  2. Tallow: Tallow is another popular lube for Muzzleloaders, as it helps to lubricate the bore and prevent fouling.
  3. Crisco: Some Muzzleloader enthusiasts also use Crisco as a lube, as it is inexpensive and readily available. However, it may not be as effective as other types of lubes.
Ultimately, the best lube for a traditional Muzzleloader will depend on personal preference and the specific needs of the gun. It's recommended to experiment with different types of lubes to find the one that works best for your particular firearm.
 
It's interesting that ChatGPT went the "It depends" route.

And has been pointed out, any lube with a lot of water in it will clean black powder fouling. Any patch lube that keeps the fouling soft will keep the shooter firing.
 
I,ve used Bore Butter for several years ,along with many other concoctions.I never did find out the exact contents,but I think Your pretty close.Bore Butter is a very contraversial subject on the CVA Forum.Several in-liners claim it caused their barrels to rust.I,ve always had good luck with it in my sidelocks. I still think the problem they have is caused by "not" getting all the moisture out of the bores.I've used every kind of lube/preserveitive to keep my guns from rusting includeing old motor oil off the dip stick.Never had a problem as long as the metal was dry!Good chance several folks will jump in here and offer up their opinions,good and bad. /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/cool.gif ::
the people that claim its no good Dont know how to preserve the barrel.. They put it in damp barrels and seals the moisture
 
Natural Lube 1000 is the only thing I've put in the bores of my muzzleloaders for the past 15 years...starting in the late 80's with a Knight inline...then through and including a number of TC Hawken percussions & flintlocks, using both Pyrodex and Goex.

They're all still as clean as the day I bought them...the bore problems people complain about come from a bore not being:bore butter
1) 100% completely clean
2) 100% completely dried
3) 100% completely lubed
If #1 and #2 are done properly, any lube will do to prevent rust...but I'll keep using NL 1000 because not only is it a good a good bore lube, it's my maxi-hunter lube, it's an excellent patch lube, and it lets me shoot all day without wiping between shots...
you do know that there's no difference between 1000, and bore butter or wonder lube there all the same just private labeled. i buy mine in a gallon jug 6 at a time for the past 35 years and everything you said goes for me and my kids and extended family
 
I use Bore Butter only as an after cleaning coat/protectant...not for projectile lube.

For that I use a lambs tallow/beeswax/olive oil blend.

Not criticising other people's ideas, I just think Bore Butter is more 'sticky' than 'slick.'

- Sentry44
 
I have friends that use bore butter for patches and after cieaning the barrel. I use robbing alcohol and Murphy's oil soap as a patch pub and oil after cleaning. Both work. As said above the barrel needs to be dry. Years ago I found that all cleaning patches are not the same. Some material has sizing on it and this prevents it from quickly absorbing water. You think the barrel is clean when it is not. Test your cleaning patch by placing a drop of water on it and see if it is quickly absorbed. If not, get 100% cotton cleaning patches and see if this eliminates the rust.
 
They'll be asking AI what's the best lube 🤣 here's what ChatGPT said:

What is the best lube for a traditional Muzzleloader?

The best lube for a traditional Muzzleloader depends on the type of bullet and powder being used. Some common types of lubes for Muzzleloaders include:

  1. Beeswax: Beeswax is a common lube for Muzzleloaders, as it provides a good barrier against fouling and helps to reduce friction.
  2. Tallow: Tallow is another popular lube for Muzzleloaders, as it helps to lubricate the bore and prevent fouling.
  3. Crisco: Some Muzzleloader enthusiasts also use Crisco as a lube, as it is inexpensive and readily available. However, it may not be as effective as other types of lubes.
Ultimately, the best lube for a traditional Muzzleloader will depend on personal preference and the specific needs of the gun. It's recommended to experiment with different types of lubes to find the one that works best for your particular firearm.
Exactly. The best live and cleaning products are what works best for you.
 
I've tried Hoppe's #9, but my office is small, and it smells too strong, so I switched to Elon Musk.
‘Tis a manly smell and often not preferred by women and those less manly. 😜

I was going to get the car air fresheners, but they’re too expensive. In fact, I use this soap… it’s great.
IMG_4296.jpeg
 
You sure it’s the lube and not a patch/ball problem or just a very rough bore.
I have no idea. I am still very much a beginner in regards to black powder. It could be all or any one of those things. I will say that the bore is shiny but it does have what looks like circular tooling marks. It has a few small scattered pits but is by no means a sewer pipe. I can tell you that recovered patches are frayed around the edges. As far as patches and balls go I have been using .010 pre lubed patches and .490 round ball. I also have the same issues when I have tried using the modern projectiles we aren't allowed to talk about here. I mention them only because it might help with a diagnosis.
 
On April 11, 2004, Roundball wrote the 3 most important aspects of rust prevention. #1 Completely clean. #2 Completely dry. #3 Completely lubed. If all 3 are done, Bore Butter will prevent rust, as shown by my several BP guns and our hot humid summers. Not a spot of rust to be found. I am, however, very anal/OCD about the clean/dry/lubed thing, so there's that.
 
It is interesting to note that Bore Butter and other greases will darken and harden in the bore over time. Many times a patch run through a barrel with a liberal application of Bore Butter will come out looking like the bore is hopelessly rusted. But also, the Bore Butter will seal in some fouling and rust forms under the intended Bore protector.

As noted, the bore must be scrupulously clean before applying Bore Butter or a heavy grease.
 
Back
Top