• This community needs YOUR help today. We rely 100% on Supporting Memberships to fund our efforts. With the ever increasing fees of everything, we need help. We need more Supporting Members, today. Please invest back into this community. I will ship a few decals too in addition to all the account perks you get.



    Sign up here: https://www.muzzleloadingforum.com/account/upgrades

A Bad Fly or A Trash Lock?

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Joined
Nov 11, 2011
Messages
4,364
Reaction score
10,886
Location
Surry County, North Carolina
This 7 month-old small Siler lock is not engaging at half cock much. It will 'click in' half cock fine several times and then it will roughly skip over the half-cock but engage solidly at full cock. This happens both on and off the gun so I believe it's not a lock mortise issue. Also, I checked the bridle and its not too tight nor loose.
Interestingly, when the lock isn't engaging at half cock, if I give the side plate a good stiff tap, it will thereafter click nicely into half-cock a few more times. (That's why I think it's a bum fly). Same thing when it's off the gun; a good tap on the cock screw head and it will then engage in half-cock.
I have it very well lucubrated with clipper oil.
I compared it with another small Siler lock I have and in comparison it looks really crude and obviously unpolished. It's on my Sparrow pistol, so I was wondering if rather than sending it off to be repaired ($$$), maybe I can take the lock apart myself (a first time doing that for me) and just remove the fly. Or, is this lock just trash? (Pics attached)
I'm bummed that I have to do this with a new lock that came from a pretty reputable dealer.
Thanks,
Bob
 

Attachments

  • IMG_8759.jpg
    IMG_8759.jpg
    333.5 KB · Views: 3
  • IMG_8760.jpg
    IMG_8760.jpg
    359.5 KB · Views: 0
Last edited:
does the rifle use a set trigger? if it does not you can just get rid of the fly and see if that fixes your issue. if you do have a set trigger, I would take the lock apart and clean and lubricate. the fly might be getting hung up and not moving properly. also check for metal burs. if the issue persists I would but a replacement fly and try that.
 
does the rifle use a set trigger? if it does not you can just get rid of the fly and see if that fixes your issue. if you do have a set trigger, I would take the lock apart and clean and lubricate. the fly might be getting hung up and not moving properly. also check for metal burs. if the issue persists I would but a replacement fly and try that.
I noted that it's on a pistol. I am leaning toward your thought about removing the fly all together, if it looks like the rest of the parts are OK.
 
The fly looks too short, the tip should be a tiny bit higher so the sear will drag it back as you cock the lock. Having a fly in the lock even without a set trigger insures the sear doesn’t catch in half cock when fired. Your tumbler has the fly on the outside so replacing it shouldn’t be difficult. Use a main spring vice though.
6AD4B69C-3E1C-47CE-B512-BEBA21611112 by Oliver Sudden, on Flickr
 
Last edited:
The fly looks too short, the tip should be a tiny bit higher so the sear will drag it back as you cock the lock. Having a fly in the lock even without a set trigger insures the sear doesn’t catch in half cock when fired. Your tumbler has the fly on the outside so replacing it shouldn’t be difficult. Use a main spring vice though.
Thanks Phil.
But Why would it not work unless I tap the lock though? I was guessing it wasn’t smooth and getting caught. And I wonder if new flies for this lock are sold already hardened?
 
I’m on the deburr, clean and lubricate team. Easy to do. With a stone or wet paper on a flat surface, knock off any burrs and polish all surfaces that rub against each other. Clean everything up and re-assemble, then lubricate the moving parts with the lightest quality oil you have. Not guaranteed, but will likely solve your issue. If not, report back.
 
Thanks Phil.
But Why would it not work unless I tap the lock though? I was guessing it wasn’t smooth and getting caught. And I wonder if new flies for this lock are sold already hardened?
It maybe just a that close to working that the tap is shaking it over.
Ask the seller and if it isn’t it’s very easy to harden.
 
Hi Bob,
Cycle the lock without the fly to assure that it is the fly that is the problem. It may be that the tip of the fly is too short such that the sear does not catch it pushing it back to uncover the half cock notch when you are bringing the flintcock back to half cock. That it works a few times after tapping the gun may simply mean the fly rotates OK and you are knocking it back on the tumbler when you tap the gun but your sear just doesn't catch it. It looks short to me in the photos. When you cock the lock, you should feel the sear riding over the fly as you go from half to full cock. If you don't feel that very slight bump, it may be another indicator that the fly is too short. You can get replacements that are already hardened and tempered. With the lock out of the gun, you should be able to see what is happening as you cock the lock. There is a good "sticky" thread at the top of the list for this Gunbuilder's Bench forum about taking a lock apart. It might be worth reviewing.

dave
 
Hi Bob,
Cycle the lock without the fly to assure that it is the fly that is the problem. It may be that the tip of the fly is too short such that the sear does not catch it pushing it back to uncover the half cock notch when you are bringing the flintcock back to half cock. That it works a few times after tapping the gun may simply mean the fly rotates OK and you are knocking it back on the tumbler when you tap the gun but your sear just doesn't catch it. It looks short to me in the photos. When you cock the lock, you should feel the sear riding over the fly as you go from half to full cock. If you don't feel that very slight bump, it may be another indicator that the fly is too short. You can get replacements that are already hardened and tempered. With the lock out of the gun, you should be able to see what is happening as you cock the lock. There is a good "sticky" thread at the top of the list for this Gunbuilder's Bench forum about taking a lock apart. It might be worth reviewing.

dave
Thanks Dave.
I will try and take the lock apart today (a first for me). I am going to look over the thread on disassembling a lock. I hope I don't mess it up.
 
Got it!
I took the lock apart down to the exposed tumbler and removed the lil' fly. The parts sure don't seem polished in there, and seeing scratch marks on the plate under the sear. Anyway, I reassembled it without the fly, oiled it with clipper oil and it goes into half-cock every time correctly. It doesn't feel as smooth as my other small Siler, but it is OK for now.
I will see if I can find a fly for this guy and get 'er right.
Thanks everyone!
 

Attachments

  • fly.jpg
    fly.jpg
    90.3 KB · Views: 0
  • fly 2.jpg
    fly 2.jpg
    150.7 KB · Views: 0
Last edited:
The fly doesn’t look damaged from what I can see in the photos, but it may be a tad short or worn short.
I agree with you and Dave Person. The fly looks to be a bit too short with the grind geometry off, not properly kicking the fly out of the way when cocked. Send the rascal back for repair/replacement.
 
It looks like a kit. Those rough parts aren't typical of a lock from Chambers. This is a learning opportunity. Disassemble it and polish all the contacting surfaces. A new fly is already hardened and can be replaced.
 
Back
Top