• This community needs YOUR help today. We rely 100% on Supporting Memberships to fund our efforts. With the ever increasing fees of everything, we need help. We need more Supporting Members, today. Please invest back into this community. I will ship a few decals too in addition to all the account perks you get.



    Sign up here: https://www.muzzleloadingforum.com/account/upgrades

“Aging” an Old Hickory knife

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Nice collection of fur trade and later I. (John) Wilson knives by Notchy Bob. As you can see there is no set rule on pins - 5 or 6 on the handles. The tepped half tang on the one blade is interesting. I doubt if a mountaineer would go out of his way to "patina" a new Sheffield butcher or scalping knife. Natives liked their tools polished or finished, especially fire steels. A trapper would be pretty old and in the mountains a long time to have a clorox etched knife or rifle barrel.
 
Nice collection of fur trade and later I. (John) Wilson knives by Notchy Bob. As you can see there is no set rule on pins - 5 or 6 on the handles. The tepped half tang on the one blade is interesting. I doubt if a mountaineer would go out of his way to "patina" a new Sheffield butcher or scalping knife. Natives liked their tools polished or finished, especially fire steels. A trapper would be pretty old and in the mountains a long time to have a clorox etched knife or rifle barrel.
Thank you, @beardedhorse

I can't explain the "stepped" configuration of the tang of that Wilson blade. I think I got that off EBay exactly as you see it. I originally intended to re-haft it with beech, as I had a couple of other originals in hand which I could use as a guide to get it right. However, I decided it might actually be of more value to me and to others who see it if I leave it as it is, so we can see how the bare tang looks.

The pin patterns interest me. All of the Russell Green River knives I have seen have full tangs and five pins in a 2-1-2 pattern. The early Wilsons have tapered half-tangs but are hafted with two scales attached with six pins in a 2-1-1-2 pattern. The John Nowill knife pictured is of recent manufacture, and has a full tang with two scales attached with four pins in a 2-1-1 pattern. However, there is an old trade knife in the McCord Museum which is hafted exactly like that, although I don't know who made it.

The Shapleigh knives also interest me. I've seen several northern plains sheaths from the later 19th century "reservation era" which housed Shapleigh butcher knives. Shapleigh's Hardware was founded in 1843 in St. Louis, but I don't know when they started providing cutlery for trade or possibly for annuities. The 1843 stamped on the blade commemorates this founding year, and is not the date the blade was manufactured. Early Shapleigh knives had two scales attached with six pins in a 2-2-2 pattern, as on the old original in the last photo. The Shapleigh company soldiered on into the early 20th century, and the butcher knives from that late era used brass cutler's rivets. The Shapleigh name was acquired by Old Hickory at some point, and most of the later Shapleigh butcher knives have the Shapleigh trademark on the blade, but "Old Hickory" stamped or branded on the handle. Old Hickory eventually dropped the Shapleigh name and trademark altogether, probably around World War II.

The six-pin Shapleigh knives are pretty scarce, but the later riveted ones are not too hard to find. Many of these have broken rivets, and of the ones I have examined, the brass rivet heads are paper-thin. I think these were probably just pressed into the wood and then ground flush, rather than being properly countersunk. I would consider this a manufacturing shortcut. However, the blades are of good steel. I love 'em.

Best regards,

Notchy Bob
 
I have used cold blue then wrapped the blade in bleach soaked cloth for an hour or two, then rub it back with steel wool and oil it with an edible oil , I once wrapped a blade in corduroy cloth soaked in bleach , the blade came out looking like it was Damascus .
Don't let your knife be used as a kitchen knife , it will end up cutting on a stainless bench top and going through the dish washer , the dish washer will kill the handle quicker than you can make another one , especially bone or antler ones .
 
Want "patina"? Management (my wife) ages all knives by hard use and frequent sharpening as did her mother and grandmother (same knives passed down like menfolk pass down guns). A couple have to be 19th century and testimony to their makers. No stainless steel. Re-handled occasionally (probably by husbands), and used for everything from butchering, cooking, digging bulbs, trimming rose bushes, skinning critters, and shaking at me for emphasis during "discussions". Old knives and old women can cut stuff.
 
I doubt if a mountaineer would go out of his way to "patina" a new Sheffield butcher or scalping knife. Natives liked their tools polished or finished, especially fire steels. A trapper would be pretty old and in the mountains a long time to have a clorox etched knife or rifle barrel.
That's not really the point, is it? When it comes to artificially aging something, there's always the argument, "just use it and let it age naturally". Well, most of us will never use these things to the point that that will happen. Many of us will never live that long. For me, these are hunting knives and in the year 2022, we're not hunting, skinning or butchering critters all year long. We may go all year and not get to use them on a dead deer, rabbit, squirrel, etc.. Not to mention that the new stuff now, doesn't look like the new stuff then. You often have to completely strip and refinish what's new now to make it look more like what was new then.

So that argument really doesn't mean anything.

Not to even mention that this is also how many of us "make it ours". Anybody can just buy something and use it.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top