• This community needs YOUR help today. We rely 100% on Supporting Memberships to fund our efforts. With the ever increasing fees of everything, we need help. We need more Supporting Members, today. Please invest back into this community. I will ship a few decals too in addition to all the account perks you get.



    Sign up here: https://www.muzzleloadingforum.com/account/upgrades

Buying my son a Flintlock for Christams

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Just my opinion:

A T/C or Traditions would be an excellent starter. There will be a learning curve, and mistakes happen. It is much easier to forgive a mistake made with a less expensive rifle. Once you have more knowledge and experience in handling them, you can consider getting one of the hand crafted rifles.
 
I am seriously grateful to everyone for your input, as the clock is ticking toward that merry day, and I really want my gift to be one that has lifetime memories. I can only hope that one day in the future he will pull it out to shot with his son and explain how it was his first BP rifle and a Christmas gift from Grampa, just like the story my dad told me when I was 8 and he taught me to shot my most cherished revolver, a Ruger Single Six, that his father bought him for Christmas in 1954. Like the Ruger, which passed the test of time, your expert opinions are going a long way to help me find the right rifle. I must say Spikebuck's link to the Pedersoli Pennsylvania 50 made my heart race. Though more than I want to spend, I am very tempted given the deep discount , comb height issue he made reference to, and stunning looks . With that said, the TC is still a strong contender, admittedly because New Hampshire is stamped on the barrel, where my family has lived for almost 400 years, and everyone seems to agree on the quality, albeit a lock upgrade desirable.
 
Be aware of the idiosyncracies of flinters vs cap guns;

1.) For flint you MUST use real BP, which can some times be problematic to find. Not a big deal if you plan ahead for it.

2.) Same thing with flints. You have to plan ahead. Real BP and flints are generally not to be found at the average gun store or big box sporting goods store.

3.) You have to be aware of keeping your flints sharp, and properly oriented and the cock jaws tight. On the range most of us tend to push it until we get a clatch, but for hunting new or sharp flints are a must.

4.) The touch hole has to be kept clear. A little bit of wettish fouling in there will obstruct the flash through the hole.

5.) No matter how fast it is, it is still going to have a longer barrel dwell time than a cap gun, which makes accuracy more challenging, especially from unstable positions. like standing. If he's a newish shooter, and of just moderate skill, this may be a source of frustration for him. Cap guns will be similarly fast to cartridge guns, and similarly accurate that way. So the "frustration factor" may be less.

6.) Flint guns will take about 10% more powder to generate the same velocities due to the gas escaping through the touch hole.

All that being said, flint IS a lot more fun to shoot, and is just as reliable, but it is a bit more finicky to keep everything working consistently. You have to pay much closer attention to protocol with flint.

As to caliber, a 50 will be more versatile, and loads can be kept tame (like 30 gr.). If you NEED to find things in a hurry, the 50 is the most popular caliber, so if they carry BP supplies at all, it will likely be for a 50. The 45 isn't far behind though.
 
I am happy to say the search is over. I am sending Torpedo a money order for what appears to be a very fine TC Hawken. I went to the Kittery Trading Post today to handle their traditional Muzzle loaders, about twenty of them, but only one flinter which appeared to be someones not so perfect attempt at a kit. It was a good time because I used the information gathered here to compare , feeling the difference between the Renegade or New Englander stock compared to the Hawken . Though the renegade style did feel more natural to me coming from a center fire world, my son specifically asked for a Flintlock, and something traditional. I feel 100% certain that getting a rifle from some one in this community is better than taking my chances with the one off the self locally, or a Traditions online.
 
Since he specifically asked for flint then get him flint. All I was saying with my earlier post is that due to the nature of them, they will be more challenging for him to achieve quick success with, so by all means you should help him manage his expectations that way.
 
I am happy to say the search is over. I am sending Torpedo a money order for what appears to be a very fine TC Hawken. I went to the Kittery Trading Post today to handle their traditional Muzzle loaders, about twenty of them, but only one flinter which appeared to be someones not so perfect attempt at a kit. It was a good time because I used the information gathered here to compare , feeling the difference between the Renegade or New Englander stock compared to the Hawken . Though the renegade style did feel more natural to me coming from a center fire world, my son specifically asked for a Flintlock, and something traditional. I feel 100% certain that getting a rifle from some one in this community is better than taking my chances with the one off the self locally, or a Traditions online.

Sounds like you made a good choice, one that you'll both be happy with for years to come!
 
He is happy, and so am I. It was a truly memorable Christmas.
IMG_0394.JPG
Thanks to Torpedo
 
Back
Top