• This community needs YOUR help today. We rely 100% on Supporting Memberships to fund our efforts. With the ever increasing fees of everything, we need help. We need more Supporting Members, today. Please invest back into this community. I will ship a few decals too in addition to all the account perks you get.



    Sign up here: https://www.muzzleloadingforum.com/account/upgrades
  • Friends, our 2nd Amendment rights are always under attack and the NRA has been a constant for decades in helping fight that fight.

    We have partnered with the NRA to offer you a discount on membership and Muzzleloading Forum gets a small percentage too of each membership, so you are supporting both the NRA and us.

    Use this link to sign up please; https://membership.nra.org/recruiters/join/XR045103

Grizz with a 50 RB

Muzzleloading Forum

Help Support Muzzleloading Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
I would not purposely hunt a grizzly with a 50 caliber roundball, though I would not hesitate going after one with a 62 caliber roundball and proper backup. But it would have to be the perfect setup.

While not a grizzly bear, there are folks out there with blowguns using hatpin sized darts with small broadheads on them getting pass throughs on deer and killing black bear and hogs. All comes down to knowing your quarry’s anatomy and shot placement.
 
All of the comments don't address one important fact that I forgot to mention. If your well aimed shot from your perfect setup doesn't bring down the bear for some reason you, or your guide if you have one, are morally, ethically, and probably legally bound to hunt the wounded bear down and kill it. This is where things can get really sticky really fast.
 
I would not purposely hunt a grizzly with a 50 caliber roundball, though I would not hesitate going after one with a 62 caliber roundball and proper backup. But it would have to be the perfect setup.

While not a grizzly bear, there are folks out there with blowguns using hatpin sized darts with small broadheads on them getting pass throughs on deer and killing black bear and hogs. All comes down to knowing your quarry’s anatomy and shot placement.

We see the videos and hear the stories of the ones that were killed but how often do we see or hear about the others that wandered off wounded by folks using this kind of method?
 
I hunt where they live. Even during muzzleloader season I pack 44 mag with 300 grain hard cast. My brother jumped one off an elk carcass while we were ML huntin, many years ago, so we closed ranks. No unmentionable MLs or bullets allowed in Idaho, we had sidelocks with 54 cal boolits. Better to be in a group with POed grizzly around.:oops:
 
We see the videos and hear the stories of the ones that were killed but how often do we see or hear about the others that wandered off wounded by folks using this kind of method?
I am not that judgmental, though I personally don’t think what they are doing is a good idea (likely because of my skill level and confidence with a blowgun), the same as my opinion about 50 caliber roundballs on grizzly. But in reality, I have heard from people that in their opinion it is cruel to hunt with a flintlock, or any type of muzzleloader for that matter, or archery tackle, or heaven forbid, a handgun. Just insert the method you don’t approve of into your statement about game wondering off and you are good to go. And then there is the all hunting is cruel crowd (I usually have Thanksgiving dinner with a few of those, and always bring a smoked wild turkey to setup next to their tofu/veggie turkey, and guess which one the kids love?) and should be banned. If it’s a legal method and a legal season, no matter what I think of the method, I am ultimately for it. As hunters we can not be fighting among ourselves about what method is best. We need to strive for skilled hunters making clean kills, no matter the weapon of choice. Or we will all soon be banned to to wherever it is folks get banned to.
 
Last edited:
I would not purposely hunt a grizzly with a 50 caliber roundball, though I would not hesitate going after one with a 62 caliber roundball and proper backup. But it would have to be the perfect setup.

While not a grizzly bear, there are folks out there with blowguns using hatpin sized darts with small broadheads on them getting pass throughs on deer and killing black bear and hogs. All comes down to knowing your quarry’s anatomy and shot placement.

Just because its possible doesn't mean you should...imo Tim wells is a bit of a tool for doing a lot of the stuff he does...
 
There been a bunch of Grizzlies killed with wood arrows so 50cal shouldn't be a problem.
Elephants have been killed with wood arrows and broadheads.....doesn't mean its not a risky endeavour and you'd never actually stop one from killing you if it was attacking with one....
 
Just one mans opinion. I am not a fan of "trophy" hunting, killing just to kill, to satisfy your ego. I do not particularly like bows for hunting because they do not kill quickly, cleanly, because many hunters take shots they shouldn't take. IMHO. Any idiot who thinks hunting with a spear, large knife, blowgun and other asinine methods is a good idea, needs to seek professional help. I was brought up in a family that hunted and my Grandfather was a professional hunter/guide who hunted all 4 Continents. I just feel that many animals especially predators, bears etc have a hard enough time living, with constant pressure from over building, logging, tourists and "outdoorsey types" invading & destroying habitat, that I do not need to add to their problems. Some species like deer, in certain States, need to be hunted to maintain a balance or they will literally over populate and eat themselves into a starvation mode, when the food source is decimated. Their biggest threat is from cars & hunters! I think if you hunt, and I did for several years, you need to do it properly, in the environment, on foot, not in a 4x4 atv, pick up, or other transport. If you are fat, lame & lazy that is your problem, deal with it. You need to use a proper firearm for the game, and know what an ethical shot is. I hunted upstate Penna. It was single digit temps, knee deep snow, rough mountainous terrain. We hunted deer the hard way, not sitting in a tree or stand, because deer do not look up. We tried to do it right. Every deer I took, I donated to the local Sr. Citizen Ctr. in town (Bradford) and they were delighted to get it. Free meat. I stopped hunting after a few years because I just did not get any enjoyment out of "killing" animals. My brother still hunts every year, same places,. he is 75 I am 71. He still enjoys the "hunt".
 
Elephants have been killed with wood arrows and broadheads.....doesn't mean its not a risky endeavour and you'd never actually stop one from killing you if it was attacking with one....
Bigpete your right there! but you could be killed in a car crash or by some crazy person I'll take may chances in the woods. I have photographed a bunch of Grizzly bears and they know they are bad asses be smart and respect them.
 
Bigpete your right there! but you could be killed in a car crash or by some crazy person I'll take may chances in the woods. I have photographed a bunch of Grizzly bears and they know they are bad asses be smart and respect them.
The bear is a tough foe. My Grandfather has one , that killed two guides they were with. Bears are fast & lethal at cl
Bradford4.jpg
ose range!
 
I couldn't find the nature photo thread so I'll post this photo here. This was taken on the Haines Road in far Northern British Colombia on the way home to Haines Alaska. We saw the bear walking toward us on the highway so I pulled over and waited to see what it would do. Keep in mind that there is very little traffic on this 150 mile long road. The bear kept coming toward us on the opposite side of the road so I got out the camera and waited with one foot on the brake, one foot on the gas pedal, one hand on the steering wheel and the other holding the camera. The bear just walked by us like we weren't even there and even the sound of the camera didn't concern him. I guess that's the attitude you can get when your the toughest guy in the room.
DSCN1057.jpeg
 
these are just small Idaho Griz. guess who felt like a mouse while they kept us in our house for 5 hours?
with the right planning, circumstances, and placement, a .50 would do the job. but, one upscrew and guess who is going to win?
 

Attachments

  • DSC00667_zpse7e79fe9.jpg
    DSC00667_zpse7e79fe9.jpg
    146.1 KB · Views: 25
  • DSC00676_zps599b98f1.jpg
    DSC00676_zps599b98f1.jpg
    134.2 KB · Views: 24
  • DSC006722_zpscecd77b7.jpg
    DSC006722_zpscecd77b7.jpg
    107.7 KB · Views: 25
Back
Top