Muzzleloading Forum .....


Contact - Can't Login?

Please, no "Good Deals" or "Sale Items" This area is for discussing the vendors themselves.

Login Name Post: Middlesex Village Trading Co        (Topic#306204)
Scipio 
32 Cal.
Posts: 44
01-09-18 05:04 PM - Post#1662361    


Gentlemen:

My advice, go somewhere else. If MVTC is the only place that carries the item you want, wait until someone else carries the item you want or have someone you trust make it for you.

Ordered a 'in stock' firearm from MVTC in early Nov. Although I do understand that it takes MVTC time to tune and prep one of the firearms they get from India, I figured six to eight weeks should be enough. After all, it was shown as 'in stock' when I paid for it. My assumptions were completely wrong. After eight weeks, it became apparent to me that I would not receive the item within several years, if at all.

You can ask the owner of MVTC any question you want and he will refer you to his 'Terms and Conditions' that he will emphasized YOU SIGNED. When you read his Terms and Conditions you see 'most items are sent out within four to six weeks, but some take longer -- much longer.' He will refer you to his 'To Do' list as the only means he will use to communicate with you about the status of your order.

Before you even think about sending him your money, you better look at his 'To Do' list first. Note he does not date anything. Then understand that no matter what you ordered, you will be put on the end of his list. I was over 160 on his list when I made my order. He indicates that he is working on a firearm if he notes "Waiting for Prep". In the nine weeks I waited, I gained six spots on his list. All six were from guys who apparently cancelled their orders. He claims he tries to update his list (only means of communicating status with his customers) once a week but it may be longer, much longer. About every three or four weeks he will update his list and if you want to complain about his lack of communications, he openly says he will 'delete your e-mail with no response'.

In the nine weeks I was on his list, there was only one firearm he claims that he actually completed. Do the math. His own work list was showing was that I would be waiting about six or seven years before he got to my firearm, that was 'In Stock' when I paid for it.

I cancelled my order, with a snide comment from the owner of MVTC, and about the only thing I can say positive about it is that I wasn't charged the 20% cancellation fee. Not because it is illegal either. MVTC has the legal right to charge you that money if they want.

Maybe this guy was top of his game many years ago. Maybe he can turn a mediocre Indian made muzzle loader into a work of art. Not sure because in the nine weeks he had my money, he only completed one firearm for someone.

Be warned.

Scipio






 
tenngun 
Cannon
Posts: 6831
tenngun
01-10-18 04:18 PM - Post#1662593    

    In response to Scipio

I’ve looked at his page a lot but never done business with him. It’s sad because it looks like a fair deal for the price, however I’ve heard your complaints from others. His FAQ is good advice.
It makes me sad because most of our online dealer in this sport are so above board.

Edited by tenngun on 01-10-18 04:19 PM. Reason for edit: No reason given.

 
Scipio 
32 Cal.
Posts: 44
01-10-18 08:05 PM - Post#1662664    

    In response to tenngun

TG:

I am not particularly angry about his failure to provide an in stock item to me within a reasonable period of time. He gave a full refund. About the only thing that angered me was his belligerent and caustic attitude towards his own customers. That is pretty astounding.

He needs to come clean with those on his 'to do' list as to why he seems unable to finish more than one firearm in two plus months and how long they can expect to wait for their product. Then let them decide if they want to stick it out. Fat chance...

Be warned guys.

Scipio




 
Loyalist Dave 
Cannon
Posts: 6236
Loyalist Dave
01-11-18 07:49 AM - Post#1662720    

    In response to Scipio

The best way to buy MVTC muskets is when they are offered for a hands-on inspection before you buy...., and you can choose and leave with the item in hand. I've seen large variations in what is offered even when they were shipped by lot to a dealer.

Which is one reason why I've done business with Loyalist Arms out of Canada for anything that I buy sight-unseen when it comes to muskets.

LD

 
Scipio 
32 Cal.
Posts: 44
01-11-18 11:12 AM - Post#1662770    

    In response to Loyalist Dave

LD:

My thoughts were the same when it comes to MVTC. If you can walk into the place and walk out with the item, go for it. One problem with that one. About 2400 miles. No excuse for his antics though. None.

I agree about Loyalist Arms. Because of your specific advice on one of the forums (that I also trust), I wrote them and they responded within 12 hours. Very polite and respectful. Also did not hesitate to give me a due out based on what I wanted. I called them and Blair was extremely polite and took as much time as needed to discuss the item and purchase.

I fully trust Loyalist will provide me with a respectable firearm that is well tuned and reliable. And that it will be delivered within the time frame I was given. I also trust that if I need to return it or any part of it that they will actually fix it and return it extremely quickly.

Loyalist Arms -- pretty impressive so far.

Scipio



 
nhmoose 
54 Cal.
Posts: 1780
nhmoose
01-12-18 06:35 PM - Post#1663051    

    In response to Scipio

I am in the same state, about 75 miles from MVTC. After 1 phone call with them I ordered my musket from Loyalist Arms. For what that's worth.

 
AZbpBurner 
54 Cal.
Posts: 1708
AZbpBurner
01-14-18 01:40 PM - Post#1663334    

    In response to nhmoose

Pete's wife once admitted the guy was hard of hearing and quite the cranky guy. He's also a fraud. The 'lifetime guarantee' devolved into less after my musket locks' sear bent like a soft 3 penny nail. Lock return was supposed to get it properly hardened, but upon return, it was evident the guy has no metallurgical skills, and merely bent the part back into place. I got out the Casenite & fixed it myself. I subsequently offered to do hardening work for him for any lock parts he cared to send me for proper repair, but never heard back from him. Apparently he's "waaay too busy" repairing all the dozens of locks that reenactors return to him.

At the last contact attempt a couple of years ago, his wife apparently isn't doing any customer service for the old fraud anymore, either. I don't foresee him getting any repeat customers because of his poor communications skills and lack of repair knowledge. With the absence of the courtesy of a simple reply on an inquiry, I assumed Middlesex as a business, had gone T-U.

As was already mentioned, Loyalist is everything that Middlesex isn't. I rec'd. a fusil from them & it was missing a lock screw. Quick e-mail to them & by the end of the week, the part arrived in the mail.

 
Old Ford 
58 Cal.
Posts: 2366
01-15-18 09:11 AM - Post#1663474    

    In response to Scipio

Hi guys,
This is a very valuable post!
In the shooting field we are a relatively small group, so the suppliers are also few and far between.
A dishonest vendor as above casts a dark shadow on many others.
People like Track of the Wolf, Muzzle Loader Supply, and other like vendors give good service, but are restricted to supplier delivery.
Thank you for the great post!
Fred

 
Scipio 
32 Cal.
Posts: 44
01-15-18 12:25 PM - Post#1663527    

    In response to AZbpBurner

AZbpB:

At least you got your part back. Some on his now locked Facebook page apparently weren't so lucky.

I got a feeling the guy is unable to function and probably hasn't done anything for months other than doctor up his 'To Do' list to make it seem like he is accomplishing something. My bet is he spends his day on his computer insulting anyone who asks the real status of their order, or demands their money back.

I doubt he is a scammer because at least in my case he returned all of my money with only a sarcastic comment.

If I had money tied up with this guy, I would be trying to get it back.

Scipio









 
Kansas Jake 
50 Cal.
Posts: 1156
01-15-18 08:54 PM - Post#1663627    

    In response to Scipio

I was thumbing through a magazine at the local farms store today and they are still running advertisements for the uninformed. This feed back is very helpful, but also sad.

 
rj morrison 
50 Cal.
Posts: 1402
rj  morrison
01-16-18 09:24 AM - Post#1663721    

    In response to Scipio

http://www.veteranarms.com/ReproductionMuzzleloadersandFlint... check with them in us. no customs problems.

 
Zonie 
Moderator
Posts: 25943
Zonie
01-16-18 07:02 PM - Post#1663874    

    In response to Kansas Jake

I don't see any Middlesex Villiage ads in the new MUZZLELOADER or MUZZLE BLASTS magazines.

I do see them pop up in a Google search but that doesn't mean much.
Just Jim...



 
Ringel05 
45 Cal.
Posts: 754
Ringel05
01-16-18 07:08 PM - Post#1663875    

    In response to rj morrison

  • rj morrison Said:
http://www.veteranarms.com/ReproductionMuzzleloadersandFlint... check with them in us. no customs problems.


If I remember correctly these are "curry" guns, made in India which is one of the reasons their prices are so "good".
As to their quality, well the internet is full of both praise and condemnation, the metal appears to be highly polished and the wood used for stocks may be of questionable quality.
As I have no personal experience with these firearms maybe someone with hands on knowledge will be able to jump in and give their thoughts on these products.

 
Loyalist Dave 
Cannon
Posts: 6236
Loyalist Dave
01-17-18 06:22 AM - Post#1663963    

    In response to Ringel05

I wonder if you refer to the Japanese Bess as a "rice" gun, and an Italian made black powder gun as a "pasta piece"?

These have been hashed and re-hashed many times. In summation:

The best possible musket is a custom built one, both for parts quality, wood to metal fit, and authenticity of appearance.

Pedersoli makes a very good (but not excellent) copy of SLP Musket, both in appearance and in function. The model is not without its problems. Same for their French musket. The Japanese Bess was a very close second.

The guns coming out of India have a lot of variation, because contrary to urban myth, they are constructed from parts from different makers.... not a single source. They are over polished, and can have lock function problems, as well as having average wood to metal fit. The wood used for the stocks is fine quality..., it's just not a good choice for a wood to use for a gunstock, especially when compared to walnut or maple. As a group they have shown when reliable in function (and most are) to be visually closer in some cases to the proper musket for some time periods, and they do reliably shoot blanks and live rounds. At less than half the price of the Italian musket. ( FYI folks, CVA has had many more barrel failures than the Indian Bess muskets, and that was with a single model )

LD

 
BillinOregon 
Cannon
Posts: 6285
01-17-18 08:27 AM - Post#1663978    

    In response to Loyalist Dave

I have been tempted several times to order from MVTC, but have heard similar experiences with belligerent customer service. Life is too short for this.
Always hear good things about Loyalist -- and have actually bought from Charles at Veterans Arms. No complaints at all.

 
Ringel05 
45 Cal.
Posts: 754
Ringel05
01-17-18 08:48 AM - Post#1663987    

    In response to Loyalist Dave

  • Loyalist Dave Said:
I wonder if you refer to the Japanese Bess as a "rice" gun, and an Italian made black powder gun as a "pasta piece"?

These have been hashed and re-hashed many times. In summation:

The best possible musket is a custom built one, both for parts quality, wood to metal fit, and authenticity of appearance.

Pedersoli makes a very good (but not excellent) copy of SLP Musket, both in appearance and in function. The model is not without its problems. Same for their French musket. The Japanese Bess was a very close second.

The guns coming out of India have a lot of variation, because contrary to urban myth, they are constructed from parts from different makers.... not a single source. They are over polished, and can have lock function problems, as well as having average wood to metal fit. The wood used for the stocks is fine quality..., it's just not a good choice for a wood to use for a gunstock, especially when compared to walnut or maple. As a group they have shown when reliable in function (and most are) to be visually closer in some cases to the proper musket for some time periods, and they do reliably shoot blanks and live rounds. At less than half the price of the Italian musket. ( FYI folks, CVA has had many more barrel failures than the Indian Bess muskets, and that was with a single model )

LD


Just in case you've forgotten I asked about these guns when I first joined and that was the info I was given, if I remember correctly even by you. As for the Curry gun nom de guerre, it was someone on this board that pinned that on the Indian guns. I just thought it was funny so you can get off your high horse on that one with me.

 
juancho 
40 Cal.
Posts: 312
02-22-18 02:26 PM - Post#1670881    

    In response to Ringel05

I bought from these people once.
The quality was just about the worse I have ever seen.Not worth the money.
that was the last time in my life I buy anything from them, and I kept the stuff to show other people why they should NEVER buy anything from them.
Wish you luck if you do.

 
Icon Legend Permissions Topic Options
Print Topic


827 Views
Welcome Guest...
Enter your Login Name and password to login. If you do not have a username you can register one here

Login Name

Password

Remember me. Help



Login Not Working?...

Registered Members
Total: 31794
Todays
Birthdays
There are no birthdays today
Current Quote
"Good judgment comes from experience, and experience comes from bad judgment."
~ Barry LePatner

PRIVACY POLICY
FusionBB™ Version 3.0 FINAL | ©2003-2010 InteractivePHP, Inc.
Execution time: 0.289 seconds.   Total Queries: 69  
All times are (GMT-6.0). Current time is 09:55 PM
Top