Eric, Welcome to the forum! You have the great opportunity to research each rifle in depth before you decide which one would be right for you. You can use the search feature here on the forum and research each rifle finding the Pros and Cons on each. As always you can also ask any specific questions about each. The members here have decades of experience and knowledge. I am sure alot of them own both these rifles that they either purchased or built from scratch. Every detail is usually noted on each of these rifles. You have come to the greatest place to research, gain knowledge, and ultimately make informed decisions. I often ask for counsel from our members prior to making a muzzleloader purchase. They have always steered me in the right direction and have saved me from myself! A good bunch of folks who would be more than glad to give you accurate, detailed information and advice. It will give you alot of food for thought prior to making your ultimate choice. Welcome aboard! Please let us know what you decide on. Hope to hear from you in the future. Respectfully, cowboys1062 :hatsoff: