Review Listing Guidelines

When listing a product or service to be reviewed, your listing should contain the facts of the product or service, along with any photos, but be free of commentary. Your listing should not be your review. Once you've posted your listing, you may go back and review the product yourself. It's a two step process. See this listing as an example - (Just the facts, with no commentary). Example

Custom Builders
Custom builders should be listed only once, not for each product they have produced. In this case we are reviewing the overall "quality and service" of the maker, not each individual piece. The reason for this is simple - the person who purchased that particular piece is the only one who has any experience with it, so others cannot add a review. It would be the same with custom knives, shooting bags, clothing, etc.

Retailers
Retailers should be listed only once as well. Example would be Cabelas or Track of the Wolf. They are listed once, as a vendor, but we don't create a new listing for that company for each product they offer.

Manufacturers
In the case of manufactures, like Thompson Center, Navy, CVA, etc. each of their products can be listed separately, as those items stand on their own in terms of performance and function.

If you have any questions, please contact us.

webmaster@muzzleloadingforum.com